Skip to content
THURSDAY, NOVEMBER 19, 2026

Independently reported.

Politics

Alito says Congress can "turn off the lights" at the Supreme Court. What can it actually do?

The justice's remark came days after Democrats won both chambers. A plain-language Q&A on the pay clause, the Court's $174.5 million budget and what Congress has changed before.

By Rosa Delgado, Courts, Law & Health Policy

· 4 min read

An empty marble courtroom with nine high-backed chairs behind a long bench and one shaft of window light
Illustration: Trestlewire

At a glance

  • •Alito said at a Federalist Society dinner on November 12 that Congress can defund the Supreme Court and "turn off the lights."
  • •Article III bars Congress from cutting justices' pay, but clerks, security and building upkeep depend on annual appropriations.
  • •The Court received $174.5 million in fiscal 2026 and asked for $225.1 million for fiscal 2027, per the Congressional Research Service.
  • •Congress sets the number of justices by statute, currently one chief justice and eight associates under 28 U.S.C. 1.

Justice Samuel Alito told a Federalist Society dinner on Thursday, November 12, that Congress "can turn off the lights at the Supreme Court" by defunding it, days after Democrats won both chambers. Whether that is true, and how much Congress could actually do, depends on a short list of constitutional lines and a budget most people have never seen.

Alito, 76, spoke at the group's annual Antonin Scalia Memorial Dinner before more than 1,000 lawyers, according to HuffPost and The Daily Beast, both quoting The Hill. He did not mention the election or the incoming Democratic majorities. Below are the questions the remark raises, answered from the text of the law.

What exactly did Alito say?

The quote, as HuffPost and The Daily Beast reproduce it: "Congress can turn off the lights at the Supreme Court and stop everything from happening if they want to defund their activities. And there are many, many, many other things that they can do, or at least try to do." He added that preserving the independence of the judiciary matters, because without it "the Constitution as adopted in 1789 will no longer be the same."

He framed the judiciary as the least powerful branch and the most exposed. In his hand grenade, 500-pound bomb and nuclear weapon comparison, the courts are the grenade: the least dangerous, but still dangerous. He also criticized lower-court judges who, in his words, have gone "far astray" by blocking presidents' policies with "unjustified" orders.

Can Congress really switch the Court off?

Partly. Article III says judges "shall, at stated times, receive for their services, a compensation, which shall not be diminished during their continuance in office." The nine justices' paychecks are protected from cuts. Everything around those paychecks is not.

Law clerks, police, building maintenance and the clerk's office are all paid from annual appropriations. The Congressional Research Service reported in April that the Court received $174.5 million in discretionary funding for fiscal 2026, split between $163.1 million for salaries and expenses and $11.4 million for the building and grounds. The Court's fiscal 2027 request is $225.1 million. The Daily Beast describes clerks' salaries and building upkeep as the money Congress could strip away.

No bill to cut that money is pending in the sources I reviewed. HuffPost and The Daily Beast both note that Alito did not tie his warning to any specific proposal.

Has Congress changed the Court before?

Yes, on its size. The Constitution does not fix the number of justices. Federal law does: 28 U.S.C. 1 says the Court "shall consist of a Chief Justice of the United States and eight associate justices, any six of whom shall constitute a quorum." Congress can amend that statute with ordinary legislation, which is why court expansion comes up whenever one party is angry at the bench.

The Daily Beast lists term limits, new ethics rules and adding seats as ideas Democrats could pursue now that they control Congress. House Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries wrote in a letter to colleagues that they must "clean up the mess at the Supreme Court," according to the same report. That letter was part of his announcement that he would run for speaker.

Who actually decides, and who can block it?

Spending bills need a majority in both chambers and the president's signature, or a two-thirds override of a veto. President Trump holds the veto. A bill that visibly defunded the Court would run into that veto, and in the Senate most legislation needs 60 votes to advance. Those two points are our reading of the procedure, not something the sources above state, and any outcome is a forecast.

There is also a cushion. The CRS notes that the wider federal judiciary uses non-appropriated money, mainly court filing fees, to offset what it asks Congress for. The CRS table lists the Supreme Court's two accounts as ordinary discretionary appropriations.

Why say it now?

The timing is the part Alito did not address. Politico's Playbook, quoted by The Daily Beast, noted that he did not discuss threats from the White House either, including President Trump's calls to impeach judges who rule against him. On July 14, Justices Elena Kagan and Amy Coney Barrett appeared before House appropriators on the Court's fiscal 2027 request, the first justice appearance at such a hearing since 2019, according to the House Appropriations Committee. The hearing focused on security, infrastructure and staffing, a reminder that the Court already depends on Congress every year.

The next concrete step to watch is the fiscal 2027 appropriations bill that covers the judiciary. If the Court's line item shows up smaller than its $225.1 million request, the remark will have turned from a warning into a vote.

  • Samuel Alito
  • Supreme Court
  • Congress
  • judicial independence
  • appropriations

Sources

  1. 01Justice Samuel Alito Warns Congress Could 'Turn Off The Lights' At Supreme Court Days After Democrats Win Control, HuffPost via Yahoo Newsyahoo.com
  2. 02Trumpy Justice Lets Slip Greatest Fear After Dem Landslide, The Daily Beastthedailybeast.com
  3. 03Judiciary Budget Request for FY2027 (IF13206), Congressional Research Serviceeverycrsreport.com
  4. 04The Purse and the Gavel: Appropriators Review the Supreme Court's FY27 Budget Priorities, House Committee on Appropriationsappropriations.house.gov
  5. 05U.S. Constitution, Article III, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law Schoollaw.cornell.edu
  6. 0628 U.S. Code 1, Number of justices; quorum, Legal Information Institute, Cornell Law Schoollaw.cornell.edu

Corrections

No corrections have been made to this article.

About the reporter

Rosa Delgado

Legal Affairs Reporter, Trestlewire

I went to law school intending to practice, passed the bar, and then took a job covering the courts for a newspaper in San Antonio in 2002. I never looked back. Courts are where policy arguments finally have to stand up on their own, without the press conference around them.

Read full bio and all stories →

The Morning Wire

The day’s reporting, in your inbox before nine.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. We never share your address.